
Tabletop Review
The information below is not guaranteed to be free of errors.
1. Introduction
Feature RX340 NRD545 7030+ RX350 FRG100 R30C R75 E1
Cost $4250 $1800 $1500 $1200 $600 $590 $570 $500
Size* 1247 944 348 788 301 163 320 244
Size in cubic inches. Negative attributes are yellow and deal-breakers are red.
Recently Drake discontinued their venerable R8B and Eton released their E1. The E1, a
high performance portable, replaces the quality control (QC) problem laden and discontinued
Sat800 in the charts below. Tabletops are organized by Cost. Each radio has a niche.
2. SWL
SHORTWAVE LISTENING
SWL involves reception of relatively high powered broadcast signals. SAM mode enhances
reception by inserting a carrier that maintains phase with the incoming carrier. SAM reduces the
distortion caused by selective fading. All the radios below can be used for SWL.
Feature RX340 NRD545 7030+ RX350 FRG100 R30C R75
E1
SAM FAIR FAIR GOOD POOR NONE NONE GOOD GOOD
Audio FAIR POOR GOOD FAIR GOOD GOOD GOOD GOOD
Speaker POOR POOR GOOD POOR POOR POOR POOR GOOD
Memory 100 1000 400 1024 50 100 99 1700
Display FAIR GOOD FAIR GOOD FAIR FAIR GOOD GOOD
The R75 requires modification: the stock SAM and audio are POOR.
The
E1 stands out for SWL due to its Drake designed SAM, pleasant audio, big speaker,
numerous memories, and informative display. The easy-to-use E1 has separate tone controls, a
whip antenna, FM band reception, and can be readily powered using four “D” type batteries.
The $1500
7030+ is excellent for SWL but with prior QC issues. At one third the price the
E1 has a superior display, front-mounted speaker, better ergonomics, and more memories. The
7030+ SAM produces low level
heterodynes due to harmonic mixing at the “SYNC CAR MIXER”.
The
R30C can be battery operated but batteries are hard to replace and last only ~8.1
hours. The E1 can run for ~71.4 hours on alkaline batteries. The R30C has some QC issues.
The
R75 has an overly fast SAM AGC, limited fidelity, and a broken SAM. Kiwa Electronics
can fix these problems for $80 via two modifications: 1) Synchronous Detector Upgrade, and 2)
High-Fidelity Audio Filter Upgrade. The R75 SAM is sideband selectable via the 9-MHz IF 2.4-kHz
filter and its associated “outer” PBT control. The E1 needs no modification for great SWL.
Usage Tabletop Cost
SWL Eton E1 $500
Komentáře k této Příručce